A global standard used by millions of people in companies of all sizes. You can use the canvas to describe, design, challenge, and pivot your business model.
In The New, New Thing, Michael Lewis refers to the phrase business model as “a term of art.” And like art itself, it’s one of those things many people feel they can recognize when they see it (especially a particularly clever or terrible one) but can’t quite define.
That’s less surprising than it seems because how people define the term really depends on how they’re using it.
Lewis, for example, offers up the simplest of definitions — “All it really meant was how you planned to make money” — to make a simple point about the dot.com bubble, obvious now, but fairly prescient when he was writing at its height, in the fall of 1999. The term, he says dismissively, was “central to the Internet boom; it glorified all manner of half-baked plans … The “business model” for Microsoft, for instance, was to sell software for 120 bucks a pop that cost fifty cents to manufacture … The business model of most Internet companies was to attract huge crowds of people to a Web site, and then sell others the chance to advertise products to the crowds. It was still not clear that the model made sense.” Well, maybe not then.
A look through HBR’s archives shows the many ways business thinkers use the concept and how that can skew the definitions. Lewis himself echoes many people’s impression of how Peter Drucker defined the term — “assumptions about what a company gets paid for” — which is part of Drucker’s “theory of the business.”
That’s a concept Drucker introduced in a 1994 HBR article that in fact never mentions the term business model. Drucker’s theory of the business was a set of assumptions about what a business will and won’t do, closer to Michael Porter’s definition of strategy. In addition to what a company is paid for, “these assumptions are about markets. They are about identifying customers and competitors, their values and behavior. They are about technology and its dynamics, about a company’s strengths and weaknesses.”
Drucker is more interested in the assumptions than the money here because he’s introduced the theory of the business concept to explain how smart companies fail to keep up with changing market conditions by failing to make those assumptions explicit.
Insight Center
Making Money with Digital Business Models
Sponsored by Accenture
Citing as a sterling example one of the most strategically nimble companies of all time — IBM — he explains that sooner or later, some assumption you have about what’s critical to your company will turn out to be no longer true. In IBM’s case, having made the shift from tabulating machine company to hardware leaser to a vendor of mainframe, minicomputer, and even PC hardware, Big Blue finally runs adrift on its assumption that it’s essentially in the hardware business, Drucker says (though subsequent history shows that IBM manages eventually to free itself even of that assumption and make money through services for quite some time).
Joan Magretta, too, cites Drucker when she defines what a business model is in “Why Business Models Matter,” partly as a corrective to Lewis. Writing in 2002, the depths of the dot.com bust, she says that business models are “at heart, stories — stories that explain how enterprises work. A good business model answers Peter Drucker’s age-old questions, ‘Who is the customer? And what does the customer value?’ It also answers the fundamental questions every manager must ask: How do we make money in this business? What is the underlying economic logic that explains how we can deliver value to customers at an appropriate cost?”
Magretta, like Drucker, is focused more on the assumptions than on the money, pointing out that the term business model first came into widespread use with the advent of the personal computer and the spreadsheet, which let various components be tested and, well, modeled. Before that, successful business models “were created more by accident than by design or foresight, and became clear only after the fact. By enabling companies to tie their marketplace insights much more tightly to the resulting economics — to link their assumptions about how people would behave to the numbers of a pro forma P&L — spreadsheets made it possible to model businesses before they were launched.”
Since her focus is on business modeling, she finds it useful to further define a business model in terms of the value chain. A business model, she says, has two parts: “Part one includes all the activities associated with making something: designing it, purchasing raw materials, manufacturing, and so on. Part two includes all the activities associated with selling something: finding and reaching customers, transacting a sale, distributing the product, or delivering the service. A new business model may turn on designing a new product for an unmet need or on a process innovation. That is it may be new in either end.”
Firmly in the “a business model is really a set of assumptions or hypotheses” camp is Alex Osterwalder, who has developed what is arguably the most comprehensive template on which to construct those hypotheses. His nine-part “business model canvas” is essentially an organized way to lay out your assumptions about not only the key resources and key activities of your value chain, but also your value proposition, customer relationships, channels, customer segments, cost structures, and revenue streams — to see if you’ve missed anything important and to compare your model to others.
Once you begin to compare one model with another, you’re entering the realms of strategy, with which business models are often confused. In “Why Business Models Matter,” Magretta goes back to first principles to make a simple and useful distinction, pointing out that a business model is a description of how your business runs, but a competitive strategy explains how you will do better than your rivals. That could be by offering a better business model — but it can also be by offering the same business model to a different market.
Introducing a better business model into an existing market is the definition of a disruptive innovation. To help strategists understand how that works Clay Christensen presented a particular take on the matter in “In Reinventing Your Business Model” designed to make it easier to work out how a new entrant’s business model might disrupt yours. This approach begins by focusing on the customer value proposition — what Christensen calls the customer’s “job-to-be-done.” It then identifies those aspects of the profit formula, the processes, and the resources that make the rival offering not only better, but harder to copy or respond to — a different distribution system, perhaps (the iTunes store); or faster inventory turns (Kmart); or maybe a different manufacturing approach (steel minimills).
Many writers have suggested signs that could indicate that your current business model is running out of gas. The first symptom, Rita McGrath says in “When Your Business Model is In Trouble,” is when innovations to your current offerings create smaller and smaller improvements (and Christensen would agree). You should also be worried, she says, when your own people have trouble thinking up new improvements at all or your customers are increasingly finding new alternatives.
Knowing you need one and creating one are, of course, two vastly different things. Any number of articles focus more specifically on ways managers can get beyond their current business model to conceive of a new one. In “Four Paths to Business Model Innovation,” Karan Giotra and Serguei Netessine look at ways to think about creating a new model by altering your current business model in four broad categories: by changing the mix of products or services, postponing decisions, changing the people who make the decisions, and changing incentives in the value chain.
In “How to Design a Winning Business Model,” Ramon Cassadesus-Masanell and Joan Ricart focus on the choices managers must make when determining the processes needed to deliver the offering, dividing them broadly into policy choices (such as using union or nonunion workers; locating plants in rural areas, encouraging employees to fly coach class), asset choices (manufacturing plants, satellite communication systems); and governance choices (who has the rights to make the other two categories of decisions).
If all of this has left your head swimming, then Mark Johnson, who went on in his book Seizing the White Space to fill in the details of the idea presented in “Reinventing Your Business Model,” offers up perhaps the most useful starting point — this list of analogies, adapted from that book:
Related Articles
- 1 Write a Marketing Analysis Report
- 2 Develop Business Models
- 3 Enhance a Small Business Through Technology
- 4 Identify the Key Success Factors of the Industry Structure in a Business Plan
Developing a business model typically entails describing how your company operates. Writing a good business model involves answering questions about your company’s customers and product or services, as well as its marketing and distribution strategies. In addition, the model should list the roles and responsibilities of employees in achieving these goals. Analyze your organizational structures and modify them regularly to maintain a competitive edge in today’s dynamic marketplace.
1.Gather a team of people from different parts of your business to describe your current or proposed operations. Start with a brainstorming activity. Draw a picture of how your business operates on a flip chart or white board. Draw circles, label them and then connect the circles with arrows to show the interrelationships. For example, describe your customers and how they get your products or services. Indicate how you distribute your products, promote sales and generate revenue. List the basic operational tasks and who performs them.
2.Download a template or develop your own format for documenting your business model. For example, use the business model calculator template provided by the Microsoft Office Templates website to record your team’s answers to questions about financial, customer and sales aspects of your business. Your model can also include details about different groups of customers and how your products or services provide value to them. List the costs incurred to run your business, including materials, employees and production expenses. List the partners and suppliers you work with to achieve your strategic goals.
3.Analyze your options. Choose a traditional “bricks and mortar” operational business model where customers come to your store to buy products or services if your customers are local to you. If your target market is more geographically diverse, select a different approach, such as using the Internet to allow customers to order products and get them shipped to their location. Decide how to use your company resources to provide valuable products and services while maintaining a profitable business. Identify opportunities for acquiring new customers or partners. Isolate weaknesses and potential risks or threats.
4.Improve your business model by identifying more ways of providing valuable products or services to customers. Add information about potential new customers, additional value your company can provide, untapped distribution channels and customer relationships you can leverage to gain new business. List potential revenue streams. Describe how you manage resources, procedures, partners and costs. Add statistical information to your business model from the U.S. Department of Commerce to show the general industry outlook. For example, classify your customers into segments and identify the opportunities for growth.
References (3)
- “Business Model Generation: A Handbook for Visionaries, Game Changers, and Challengers”; Alexander Osterwalder and Yves Pigneur; 2010
- “Chickens and Pigs: Business Models and Competitive Strategy”; Harold Star; 2007
Resources (3)
About the Author
Tara Duggan is a Project Management Professional (PMP) specializing in knowledge management and instructional design. For over 25 years she has developed quality training materials for a variety of products and services supporting such companies as Digital Equipment Corporation, Compaq and HP. Her freelance work is published on various websites.
Photo Credits
- Michael Blann/Digital Vision/Getty Images
Choose Citation Style
Duggan, Tara. 'How to Write a Good Business Model.' Small Business - Chron.com, http://smallbusiness.chron.com/write-good-business-model-3875.html. Accessed 24 June 2019.
Duggan, Tara. (n.d.). How to Write a Good Business Model. Small Business - Chron.com. Retrieved from http://smallbusiness.chron.com/write-good-business-model-3875.html
Duggan, Tara. 'How to Write a Good Business Model' accessed June 24, 2019. http://smallbusiness.chron.com/write-good-business-model-3875.html
Note: Depending on which text editor you're pasting into, you might have to add the italics to the site name.